|Year : 2015 | Volume
| Issue : 7 | Page : 566-569
Intermittent exotropia: Surgical treatment strategies
Jai Aditya Kelkar1, Santhan Gopal2, Rachana B Shah1, Aditya S Kelkar1
1 Department of Paediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus, National Institute of Ophthalmology, Pune, Maharashtra, India
2 Kamala Nethralaya, Bengaluru, Karnataka, India
|Date of Submission||25-Jun-2014|
|Date of Acceptance||07-Sep-2015|
|Date of Web Publication||12-Oct-2015|
Dr. Jai Aditya Kelkar
National Institute of Ophthalmology, 1187/30, Off Ghole Road, Near Mahatma Phule Museum, Shivaji Nagar, Pune - 411 005, Maharashtra
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Surgical management of intermittent exotropias (IXTs) is ambiguous, with techniques of management varying widely between institutions. This review aims to examine available literature on the surgical management of IXT. A literature search was performed using PubMed, Web of Knowledge, LILACS, and the University of Liverpool Orthoptic Journals and Conference Transactions Database. All English-language papers published between 1958 and the present day were considered.
Keywords: Intermittent exotropia, strabismus surgery, success rate of intermittent exotropias
|How to cite this article:|
Kelkar JA, Gopal S, Shah RB, Kelkar AS. Intermittent exotropia: Surgical treatment strategies. Indian J Ophthalmol 2015;63:566-9
|How to cite this URL:|
Kelkar JA, Gopal S, Shah RB, Kelkar AS. Intermittent exotropia: Surgical treatment strategies. Indian J Ophthalmol [serial online] 2015 [cited 2020 Nov 30];63:566-9. Available from: https://www.ijo.in/text.asp?2015/63/7/566/167109
The management of intermittent exotropia (IXT) is controversial. This review will examine surgical aspects of IXT.
IXT is a common form of childhood exotropia, accounting for about 50–90% of all the exotropia and affecting about 1% of the general population.,,, There is a lack of longitudinal prospective study about this, and only a few retrospective studies , of untreated IXT are published.
The age of onset of IXT coincides with the age of visual maturation for children, which is between 3 and 6 years. The binocular function is often disturbed by the exotropia. As a rule, during the phoric phase of IXT, the eyes are well aligned, and the patient may have a bifoveal fixation with excellent stereopsis ranging between 40 and 60 arc second. During the tropic phase, most patients will show large regional suppression of the temporal retina and anomalous retinal correspondence. A minority of patients with IXT may have the monofixation syndrome and do not develop normal bifoveal fixation with a high grade of stereopsis. Some patients may even have a significant amblyopia.
| Clinical Presentation|| |
IXT is an exodeviation controlled by fusional mechanisms. Exotropia is usually preceded by a phase of exophoria, and the deviation is most noticeable when children are tired, sick, inattentive or after long time near reading task. Adult patients may manifest exodeviation after imbibing alcoholic beverages or taking sedatives. Patients may exhibit normal retinal correspondence when both eyes are aligned, but abnormal retinal correspondence when one eye is deviated.
Patients with late onset exotropia, that is, after the ages of 6–7 years may experience diplopia because the exotropia occurs after the loss of visual plasticity. One symptom that deserves a special comment is the closure of one eye in bright sunlight. Bright sunlight dazzles the retina so that fusion is disrupted, causing the deviation to become manifest, and resulting in the closure of one eye. Monocular eye closure in sunlight is a mechanism used to reduce photophobia and is not related to avoidance of diplopia.,
IXT could progress to constant exotropia or remain stable. In some cases, an exophoria can progress to an IXT that eventually becomes constant exotropia. Such deviation usually occurs first at a distance, but later at near fixation as well.
Dissociated horizontal deviation is defined as a change in horizontal ocular alignment, unrelated to accommodation, that is, brought about solely by a change in the balance of visual input from the two eyes. It usually manifests as a spontaneous unilateral exodeviation or an exodeviation of greater magnitude in one eye during prism and alternate cover testing. Unlike in other forms of IXT, the observed exodeviation is slow, variable, and asymmetrical in the two eyes. In some instances, fixation with one eye evokes an esodeviation of the other eye during prism and alternate cover testing.
| Etiological Factors|| |
There are many etiological factors for exotropia. Abnormal anatomy of the extra ocular muscles, loss of fusional control and/or convergence insufficiency is the most accepted explanations. It is generally considered that the lens therapy-glasses or contact lenses alone is insufficient for myopia with IXT.,, However, a study reports that implantable collamer lens restores ocular alignment and improves binocularity. Strabismus affects stereoacuity development considerably, as its onset period is just around the key phase of bifixation development. In a study of 104 patients, it was found that only about half patients with IXT could acquire and keep static distance stereoacuity after surgery over a long period. Timely surgical intervention can help restore and enhance binocular function.
| Indications for Surgery|| |
Surgery is thought to be an effective method for the treatment of IXT. Popular intervention criteria include a reduction in or loss of stereoacuity (at near or distance), deteriorating fusional control, a large angle of deviation, or a combination; but potential thresholds remain poorly defined. The goals of the surgery for IXT are to restore alignment and preserve or restore binocular function. However, the optimal time for surgical intervention remains unclear. The critical point is the postoperative stereoacuity establishment. The Newcastle Control Score is a useful measure of the clinical severity of exotropia, can be used to serially assess improvement or deterioration and is a useful tool for the management of these patients.
Nonsurgical treatment has been advocated, as has a single lateral rectus recession for small angle exotropia, but what constitutes a "small" angle and whether or not and how it should be treated remain unclear. According to a study, the presence of the monofixation syndrome after surgery for presumed IXT most likely reflects the fact that it was present preoperatively, and the term monofixational exotropia is more appropriately descriptive for these cases.
| Time of Intervention and Goals of Surgery|| |
Currently, most surgeons believe that early surgery for children is indicated to prevent progression to constant exotropia and restoration of bifixation, whereas in most adult patients surgery can only help to achieve orthotropia, but not bifoveal fixation.
Researchers have proposed that patients may achieve a superior sensory outcome with motor realignment before age 7 or < 5 years of strabismus duration., Others are of the view that the surgery needs to be postponed for several years because IXT patients can still keep IXT and hence bifixation can be obtained even if operated late and not all IXTs are progressive. In some cases, the deviation may remain stable for many years whereas, in a few cases, it may even improve. Nevertheless, some researchers thought that patients might easily achieve binocular function if operated after age 7 and over 5 years of strabismus duration.,, Favorable results after a surgical intervention before 2 years of age have also been reported by some authors.
In IXT, one important indication for therapeutic intervention is the increasing tropia phase, as this indicates a deteriorating fusional control. The increasing frequency or duration of the tropia phase indicates the diminished fusional control and potential binocular function loss. Progression should be monitored by documenting the size of the deviation, duration of manifest deviation and ease of regaining fusion after dissociation from the cover-uncover test.
Researchers have proposed that distance stereoacuity as an objective measurement and indicated the time to intervene surgically. In order to avoid diplopia and other symptoms, patients with IXT may develop anomalous retinal correspondence and/or suppression. Postoperatively, positive correcting exercises should be administered to restore normal retinal correspondence and enhance binocular function, such as the synoptophore exercise.
| Classification and Choice of Procedure|| |
Burian,,,,, classified IXT based on distance/near differences and recommended different surgical procedures based on this classification. They defined the condition of patients in whom the distance deviation equaled the near deviation as a basic type of exotropia and recommended it be treated with a unilateral recess/resect surgery. A study by Kushner also suggested the same. One study included in the Cochrane review, conducted by a single surgeon in the USA, compared surgery on one eye to surgery on both eyes in 36 children with the basic type of exotropia. Success was defined as no exotropia (or other strabismus) 1 year following surgery. The study found that surgery on one eye was more effective (82% success) than surgery on both eyes (52% success).
Patients in whom the distance deviation exceeded the near deviation were considered to have a divergence excess type of exotropia; for such patients Burian recommended symmetric lateral rectus recessions. They based these recommendations on the assumption that bilateral lateral rectus recessions would affect the distance deviation more than the near deviation, and that a recess/resect procedure would affect the distance and near deviation equally. Scobee observed that many patients with an apparent divergence excess type of exotropia would manifest an increase in their near deviation after 24 h of monocular occlusion. Subsequently, it was determined that approximately 1 h of occlusion was sufficient to elicit this increase., And surgery should be performed for the largest angle measured. Burian ,,,, defined the condition of these patients as a simulated divergence excess type of exotropia. Kushner further subdivided Burian's classification concerning the divergence excess pattern caused by an excess of divergence or by excessive accommodative convergence. Because they believed that these patients really had a near deviation that equaled the distance deviation, but that it was masked by fusional vergences at near, they recommended that they be treated as if the patients had a basic type of exotropia and underwent recess/resect surgery. Another study suggested that patients with basic type IXT should be treated with recess/resect procedures, but patients with simulated divergence excess do well with lateral rectus recessions.
Subsequently, other authors have described good results in treating patients with all 3 of these patterns of IXT with symmetric lateral rectus recessions.,
In the 18th annual Scobee Lecture, November 10, 1987, Dallas, Texas, reported that patients with a simulated divergence excess exotropia (according to Burian's classification) did as well as patients with a true divergence excess pattern if they were treated with bilateral lateral rectus recessions. However, patients with a basic type of exotropia did not do as well if treated with bilateral lateral rectus recessions as patients with either true divergence excess or simulated divergence excess exotropia. A long-term (2 years) survival analysis of bilateral lateral rectus recession versus unilateral recess-resect for IXT concluded that although the surgical outcomes were comparable in both groups, the final outcomes were better in the bilateral recession group than in the recess-resect group. This may be caused by the difference of recurrence rate over time: Continuous recurrence of exotropia in the recess-resect group while recurrence was low after 6 months of bilateral lateral rectus recession.
Bilateral lateral rectus recession has also been advocated for cases of so-called bilateral dissociated horizontal deviation or for unilateral dissociated horizontal deviation combined with exotropia.
Weakening procedures on all four obliques which are overacting in large angle exotropia had been advocated, but later it was found that such overaction of all oblique muscles is often only an apparent one that may disappear after surgery of horizontal recuts muscles.
| Surgical Outcome|| |
Due to lack of a standard definition for a successful outcome, variability in classification systems, multiple treatment approaches, and a paucity of long-term data it is difficult to determine the true outcome of currently available treatments for IXT. The success rate of IXT is dependent on the length of postoperative follow-up. Longer the follow-up higher the incidence of recurrence. In recent studies, the reported success rate in all types of IXT has been about 60–70%.,,,
Undercorrection is common after an initial bilateral lateral rectus recession with 21–31% requiring a second procedure., Use of base in prisms of power greater than residual deviation has been advocated to provoke convergence and thus lessen the exodeviation.,,
Surgical overcorrection varies according to different authors (6%, 8%, 10%, 11%, 17% and 20%) small degree of esotropia a watchful waiting is advisable. The second operation should not be performed until at least 6 months have elapsed, except when there are significant limitations of ductions that cause incomitance in lateral gaze.
A recent study  analyses the relation between age and surgical outcome in IXT. According to it, in younger patients (<7 years) in whom surgical dose was reduced, there was no significant change in success rate (77%), compared with those who had surgery using standard tables (75%). In older patients (>12 years) in whom surgical dose was increased, there was a statistically significant increase in success rate (80% vs. 41%). Thus, modifying the surgical dose according to age can improve the success in patients with IXT.
| Conclusion|| |
The preoperative deviation is one of the strongest predictors for the favorable surgical outcome.
Surgery with preoperative orthoptic/occlusion therapy had the highest success rates. Surgery with orthoptic/occlusion therapy was more effective in reducing exodeviation (prism diopters per millimeter of horizontal rectus surgery), compared with surgery alone.
Strabismus surgery can help to preserve or restore the binocular vision in IXT. Children receiving the surgery at young ages might develop better postoperative binocular vision, and the postoperative synoptophore exercise/amblyopia therapy can help to restore the binocular vision.
Short-term studies with 6 months to 1-year follow-up reports a success rates of approximately 80%, whereas studies with 2–5-year follow-up have shown a 50–60% success rate with one surgery. In most of these reports, success was defined as alignment within 10 prism diopters of orthophoria, and mean follow-up was no >4.5 years.
However, literature review suggests that more studies will help us understand the pathogenesis of the IXT and hence understand the behavioral pattern of the disease, which in turn will help us treat it better. Surgical intervention based on the stereopsis, Newcastle scores, and the fusion amplitudes give good results in terms of long-term success of the surgery. Early detection of abnormal stereoacuity for distance and near fusional vergence amplitudes may help to decide the proper timing of surgery in IXT. Thus, there is a need for robust clinical trials to improve the evidence base for the management of this condition.
Dr. Devanshi Bhanushali, MBBS.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Abroms AD, Mohney BG, Rush DP, Parks MM, Tong PY. Timely surgery in intermittent and constant exotropia for superior sensory outcome. Am J Ophthalmol 2001;131:111-6.
Chia A, Seenyen L, Long QB. A retrospective review of 287 consecutive children in Singapore presenting with intermittent exotropia. J AAPOS 2005;9:257-63.
Figueira EC, Hing S. Intermittent exotropia: Comparison of treatments. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2006;34:245-51.
Govindan M, Mohney BG, Diehl NN, Burke JP. Incidence and types of childhood exotropia: A population-based study. Ophthalmology 2005;112:104-8.
Hutchinson AK. Intermittent exotropia. Ophthalmol Clin North Am 2001;14:399-406.
Lou DH, Xu YS, Li YM. Sensory exotropia subsequent to senile cataract. J Zhejiang Univ Sci B 2005;6:1220-2.
Gharabaghi D, Azade M. Binocular vision and stereopsis. Iran J Ophthalmol 2006;19:46-50.
Vazquez R, Calhoun JH, Harley RD. Development of monofixation syndrome in congenital esotropia. J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus 1981;18:42-4.
Serrano-Pedraza I, Manjunath V, Osunkunle O, Clarke MP, Read JC. Visual suppression in intermittent exotropia during binocular alignment. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2011;52:2352-64.
Yang CQ, Shen Y, Gu YS, Han W. Clinical investigation of surgery for intermittent exotropia. J Zhejiang Univ Sci B 2008;9:470-3.
Wiggins RE, von Noorden GK. Monocular eye closure in sunlight. J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus 1990;27:16-20.
Wang FM, Chryssanthou G. Monocular eye closure in intermittent exotropia. Arch Ophthalmol 1988;106:941-2.
Pediatric Eye Disease Investigator Group. The clinical profile of moderate amblyopia in children younger than 7 years. Arch Ophthalmol 2002;120:281-7.
Rutstein RP, Corliss DA. The clinical course of intermittent exotropia. Optom Vis Sci 2003;80:644-9.
Stathacopoulos RA, Rosenbaum AL, Zanoni D, Stager DR, McCall LC, Ziffer AJ, et al.
Distance stereoacuity. Assessing control in intermittent exotropia. Ophthalmology 1993;100:495-500.
Rowe FJ, Noonan CP, Freeman G, DeBell J. Intervention for intermittent distance exotropia with overcorrecting minus lenses. Eye (Lond) 2009;23:320-5.
Coffey B, Wick B, Cotter S, Scharre J, Horner D. Treatment options in intermittent exotropia: A critical appraisal. Optom Vis Sci 1992;69:386-404.
Agrawal S, Singh V, Jain A. Corrrection of exotropia by implantable collamer lens. Indian J Ophthalmol 2013;61:685.
von Noorden GK. Exodeviations. In: Binocular Vision and Ocular Motility. 5th
ed. St. Louis: Mosby; 1996 p. 343.
Hayashi Y, Yokoyama T, Nomura F, Shiraki K. Long-term prognosis of distance stereoacuity in intermittent exotropia after strabismus surgery. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2005;46:2952.
Hatt SR, Gnanaraj L. Interventions for intermittent exotropia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2013;5:CD003737.
Buck D, Hatt SR, Haggerty H, Hrisos S, Strong NP, Steen NI, et al.
The use of the Newcastle control score in the management of intermittent exotropia. Br J Ophthalmol 2007;91:215-8.
Kushner BJ. The occurrence of monofixational exotropia after exotropia surgery. Am J Ophthalmol 2009;147:1082-5, 1085.e1.
Maruo T, Kubota N, Sakaue T, Usui C. Intermittent exotropia surgery in children: Long term outcome regarding changes in binocular alignment. A study of 666 cases. Binocul Vis Strabismus Q 2001;16:265-70.
Gill LK, Arnoldi K. Binocular vision outcomes following surgery for long-standing large angle exodeviation. Strabismus 2013;21:123-6. doi: 10.3109/09273972.2013.786743.
Simmon EP, Marcotty A, Crowe S, Traboulsi EI. Annual Meeting of the Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology. Florida: Fort Lauderdale; 2002. Surgical Out-comes in Exotropia.
Saunders RA, Trivedi RH. Sensory results after lateral rectus muscle recession for intermittent exotropia operated before two years of age. J AAPOS. 2008;12:132-5.
Wright KW, Spiegel PH, Thompson LS, editors. Handbook of Pediatric Strabismus and Amblyopia. New York, NY: Springer; 2006. p. 227-8.
Sharma P, Saxena R, Narvekar M, Gadia R, Menon V. Evaluation of distance and near stereoacuity and fusional vergence in intermittent exotropia. Indian J Ophthalmol 2008;56:121-5.
Burian HM. Selected problems in the diagnosis and treatment of the neuromuscular anomalies of the eyes. In: International Course Ophthalmology. Vol 2. Barcelona, Spain: Publications of the Institute Barraquer; 1958. p. 456-67.
Burian HM, Spivey BE. The surgical management of exodeviations. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc 1964;62:276-306.
Burian HM. Exodeviations: Their classification, diagnosis, and treatment. Am J Ophthalmol 1966;62:1161-6.
Burian HM, Franceschetti AT. Evaluation of diagnostic methods for the classification of exodeviations. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc 1970;68:56-71.
Burian HM, Smity DR. Comparative measurement of exodeviations at twenty and one hundred feet. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc 1971;69:188-99.
Kushner BJ. Selective surgery for intermittent exotropia based on distance/near differences. Arch Ophthalmol 1998;116:324-8.
Scobee RG. Exophoria. In: The Oculorotary Muscles. St. Louis, MO: CV Mosby Co.; 1952. p. 171.
Kushner BJ. The distance angle to target in surgery for intermittent exotropia. Arch Ophthalmol 1998;116:189-94.
Kushner BJ, Morton GV. Distance/near differences in intermittent exotropia. Arch Ophthalmol 1998;116:478-86.
Hardesty HH, Boynton JR, Keenan JP. Treatment of intermittent exotropia. Arch Ophthalmol 1978;96:268-74.
Parks MM. Concomitant exodeviations. In: Ocular Motility and Strabismus. Hagerstown, MD: Harper and Row; 1975. p. 113-22.
Choi J, Chang JW, Kim SJ, Yu YS. The long-term survival analysis of bilateral lateral rectus recession versus unilateral recession-resection for intermittent exotropia. Am J Ophthalmol 2012;153:343-51.e1.
Wilson ME, Hutchinson AK, Saunders RA. Outcomes from surgical treatment for dissociated horizontal deviation. J AAPOS 2000;4:94-101.
Jampolsky A. Ocular divergence mechanisms. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc 1970;68:730-822.
Ing MR, Nishimura J, Okino L. Outcome study of bilateral lateral rectus recession for intermittent exotropia in children. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc 1997;95:433-43.
Scott WE, Keech R, Mash AJ. The postoperative results and stability of exodeviations. Arch Ophthalmol 1981;99:1814-8.
Souza-Dias C, Uesugi CF. Post-operative evolution of the planned initial over-correction in intermittent exotropia: 61 cases. Binocul Vis Eye Muscle Surg Q 1993;8:141-8.
Saleem QA, Cheema AM, Tahir MA, Dahri AR, Sabir TM, Niazi JH. Outcome of unilateral lateral rectus recession and medial rectus resection in primary exotropia. BMC Res Notes 2013;6:257.
Richard JM, Parks MM. Intermittent exotropia. Surgical results in different age groups. Ophthalmology 1983;90:1172-7.
Hardesty HH. Treatment of under and overcorrected intermittent exotropia with prism glasses. Am Orthopt J 1969;19:110-9.
Hardesty HH. Prisms in the management of intermittent exotropia. Am Orthopt J 1972;22:22-30.
Knapp P. Recent advances in strabismus management. Use of membrane prisms. Trans Sect Ophthalmol Am Acad Ophthalmol Otolaryngol 1975;79:718-21.
Fletcher MC, Silverman SJ. Strabismus. I. A summary of 1,110 consecutive cases. Am J Ophthalmol 1966;61:86-94.
Von Noorden GK. Divergence excess and simulated divergence excess: Diagnosis and surgical management. Doc Ophthalmol 1969;26:719-28.
Laws HW. An evaluation of the use of prisms in the postoperative orthoptic care of divergence strabismus. In: Arruga A, editor. International Strabismus Symposium. University of Giessen, Germany, 1966. Basel: S Karger; 1968. p. 324.
Dunlap EA. Overcorrections in horizontal strabismus surgery. In: Symposium on Strabismus. Transactions of New Orleans Academy Of ophthalmology. St. Louis: Mosby-Year Book; 1971. p. 255.
Awadein A, Eltanamly RM, Elshazly M. Intermittent exotropia: Relation between age and surgical outcome: A change-point analysis. Eye (Lond) 2014;28:587-93.